Skip to content

"American Fiction" Scoops People's Choice Award at TIFF, Eyes on Oscars Next

A. Prentice

The People's Choice Award from the recently concluded 2023 Toronto Film Festival (TIFF) has been awarded to the film "American Fiction". Coming in second place is "The Holdovers", directed by Alexander Payne, closely followed by Hayao Miyazaki’s "The Boy And The Heron" as the second runner-up. The Documentary Award section saw "Mr. Dressup: The Magic Of Make-Believe" emerging at the top, while "Dicks: The Musical" bagged the Midnight Madness title.

Crime through a different lens, "American Fiction" is a joint venture of Orion and MRC, casting the versatile Jeffrey Wright. Written and directed by Cord Jefferson, the movie offers a sarcastic critique on the publishing industry, specifically on its treatment of serious works by Black writers.

The film's plot revolves around Thelonious “Monk” Ellison, a Black writer who adopts the pseudonym Sinatra Golden out of protest against intended stereotypes. Under his newly assumed identity, he presents a clichéd book titled "We’s Lives In Da Ghetto". The irony unfolds when the protest manuscript, intended to highlight the sustained stereotypes, turns into a bestseller. Now, audiences are eagerly waiting for its release in theaters this November.

Since 1978, TIFF's People's Choice Award, voted on by audience members, has long been seen as foreshadowing for the Best Picture Oscar. Past winners of this prestigious accolade that later went on to seize the Best Picture Academy Award include "Nomadland", "Green Book", "12 Years a Slave", "The King’s Speech", "Slumdog Millinaire", "American Beauty", and "Chariots of Fire".

Adding to its esteemed credibility, films such as "The Fabelmans", "Belfast", "JoJo Rabbit", "Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri", "Room", "La La Land", "The Imitation Game", "Silver Linings Playbook", "Precious", "Life Is Beautiful", "Places in the Heart" and "The Big Chill" were also awarded the People’s Choice Award and subsequently received Oscar nominations for Best Picture.

***
With the details out of the way, now let's have a heart-to-heart.

"American Fiction” stands as a redefining moment in the industry - a paradoxical narrative that pokes fun at grim truths yet leaves us unnerved with its accidental triumph. It’s not simply about writers' woes and publishing politics. It’s about representation and perception. This film serves a gut-wrenching mockery, shaming literary frontrunners for their less-than-adequate portrayal of Black life.

It’s not surprising that "American Fiction” has drawn the eyes of the TIFF audiences and is now knocking at Oscar’s door. Why? For one, movies that shake us, making us chew over societal norms and question established system, often leave a lasting impression.

Also, anyone who calls a musical "Dicks" and bags the Midnight Madness title has our attention, and arguably our applause for audacity. Your move, West End.

As for "Mr. Dressup: The Magic Of Make-Believe" winning the Documentary Award? Magic indeed. If nostalgia had a form, this would be it. Childhood recollections jumbled with the simple comfort of make-believe antics - who would not root for such enchantment?

TIFF has wrapped up another year of fabulous films, delivering on the promise of diversified content. All that remains now is to keep your popcorn ready as "American Fiction" rolls onto theatre screens this November. If its accolades are any indicator, it's shaping up to be a blockbuster with a hefty serving of food for thought. So, Hollywood, hold onto your hats; it seems we're in for a roller-coaster award season.