Silverman Softens Stand on SAG-AFTRA Interim Agreements
Sarah Silverman, renowned comedian and frequent participant on picket lines, is easing her harsh criticism of the interim agreements being doled out by the Screen Actors Guild - American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (SAG-AFTRA) throughout their ongoing strike. These agreements that the guild, which has an impressive 160,000 members, is inking to permit non-AMPTP companies' film and TV productions to press on. Silverman's softened tone comes less than 48 hours after her social media rant against the guild's flurry of deals.
Silverman revealed in her Saturday online post she had dialogued with guild president Fran Drescher and national executive director Duncan Crabtree-Ireland about the nature of these numerous approved projects: an issue SAG-AFTRA also talked about on Friday. She explained the guild's perspective, which emphasizes that these interim agreements bind indie productions to fulfill all conditions that the SAG desires. In essence, they must conform to the SAG's contract or whatever terms will eventually be agreed upon.
The guild's leadership sees these agreements as proving to AMPTP that SAG-AFTRA's demands are reasonable and achievable. Thus, if the AMPTP desires these productions, they must comply with the stipulated terms or participate in the agreement.
Despite these clarifications, Silverman retains a hint of reservation about the philosophy behind these agreements, feeling that the guild leaders may be too optimistic. She also expressed disquiet over what she views as a "loophole" that allows projects attached with big stars and distributors, including Paramount Global, to proceed.
On a note of solidarity, Silverman did state that she found it "comfortable" to agree to disagree while working together. She admitted to finding the daily picketing under harsh weather conditions crucial despite being "performative." She emphasized that the underlying cause was the strike and work stoppage, stating, "That's our power."
Silverman's latest stance, however, is a far cry from her Wednesday sentiments. Then, she branded the interim agreements as simply allowing big films to bypass the strike, and these films must conform to SAG's conditions only if they sell their product to streaming platforms.
Crabtree-Ireland, of the SAG-AFTRA, stated after Silverman's initial post that they had met with the comedian and other actors to discuss the interim agreements and stressed members' unity in the fight for fair, equitable, and respectful contracts.
Several high-profile projects that have currently scored interim agreements include Apple TV+'s series Tehran, New Line pickup The Watchers from Ishana Night Shyamalan, Glenn Close's The Summer Book, and A24 titles Mother Mary and Death of a Unicorn.
Upon analyzing Silverman's IG post, a high-profile member of the Writers Guild of America and Directors Guild of America expressed his own poignant hesitations about the interim agreements and the thinking fueling them.
While the actor's union, along with the Writers Guild of America, initiated the first joint strike since 1960 on Jul 13, all guilds and C-suites are hoping for a swift and reasonable resolution. However, no official contact has been made and no new talks are scheduled.
****************************************
Now, let's offer up the Addison Prentice take.
It seems our beloved Sarah Silverman has swapped her comedy mic for a mediator's gavel, keeping the peace between opposing forces. Silverman has previously been dubbed the 'Peacemaker of Picket Lines', but it seems this latest disagreement may be pushing her to the edge. A touch of cynicism in her voice shouldn't surprise us; after all, striking actors and industry moguls can seem as incompatible as mustard and merlot.
Interim agreements: the phrase itself has a ring of mediocrity, doesn't it? A deal that's not quite a deal, a door left slightly open for potential harsher terms. It's like the relationship status, "It’s complicated.” However, these contracts hold much more weight, and navigating these murky waters requires more than a sense of humor.
We've all heard the phrase, "the devil's in the details." Well, when it comes to AMPTP and SAG-AFTRA, it seems the devil's taken up residency in contract fine print and negotiations. It's a tale of two entities: one insisting the cookie jar is too high, the other assuring it's within arm's reach.
One must tip their hat to Silverman's efforts. She's throwing herself in the midst of diplomatic storms and attempting to articulate differing perspectives clearly and fairly. Yet, her concern about the ‘loophole’ attached to big stars and distributors like Paramount Global underscores the complexity of resolving this strike.
Silverman's grit and determination in getting back to work, alongside her peers, are admirable. The picketing, the meetings, the public declarations: it’s a soap opera that could perhaps even rival the plots of some Hollywood productions. Her candid observation that picketing, while grueling and "performative," does serve to put the issue under the spotlight.
As we mire through the next scene of this ongoing Hollywood drama, it's crunch time for the decision-makers in both camps. The sweat and tears shed on the picket lines could write a screenplay of their own. It's the kind of story we love here in Hollywood: tension, negotiation, and hopefully: a satisfying resolution. Both sides must remember that while AMPTP has a say on-screen, it’s the combined effort of the many that keeps those cameras rolling.
